HYD vs. BBF >>> Makino’s family vs. Jandi’s family

makino's family vs. jandi's family

makino's family vs. jandi's family

Hey guys!!! So before i get to it, i have a quick story to tell. Due to the limited amount of space on my computer, i’ll be having to delete my HYD and BBF episodes from my computer T_T fml. but i’m still going to continue this blog cuz it satisfies my obsession :] lol. but because of this, i’ll be spending the next week or so getting all my screen caps and videos in for the 25+ more installments coming up! this means my updating might be a little slow. sorry! Anyways, in this post i’ll be comparing Makino’s family and Jan di’s family (as indicated by the title…)

So lets start with the papas!

makino's father vs. jandi's father

makino's father vs. jandi's father

 Alright, so I’m going to start with Jandi’s father, the dry cleaner :] I think his personality is infectious and for the most part he’s always happy and you never get the feeling of saddness when you watch him, even in the parts where he’s “crying” because his crying was so fake, it was funny XD lol. with Makino’s dad, he kinda reminds me of bhudda :] cuz he’s so chubby and when he smiles his cheeks are so chubby. lol. i must say, at times i found him really annoying, personally. He was so needy of makino just because he decided to gamble off a million dollars. I remember when makino’s parents went to move to the fishing villiage and she was living with her and her brother, the parents asked the KIDS if they had any money to share. ugh, if my father said that to me, i’d be so pissed off.

makino's mother vs. jandi's mother

makino's mother vs. jandi's mother

LOL! i love that picture of jandi’s mom XD it really shows off her crazy personality…and i mean CRAZY! she’s like the typical asian mother that yells at her daughter for eating too much, pours salt on other mothers, and invites men in love with your daughter to stay the night….okay, mby not typical, but definitely crazy. lol. With makino’s mom, we didn’t see a lot of her on the show. I didn’t really get a feel of her personality and more importantly, i didn’t really see a lot of her with makino, so we couldn’t really see mother/daughter bonding.

susumu vs. kang san

susumu vs. kang san

Ahhhh, so now we review the little bros. Starting with Kang san. HE’S SO CUUUTEEEE :] he has the chubbiest cheeks and when he smiles it’s even cuter (i love it when he says “noona” he’s so cute when he says it! lol). Its so adorable how they make him a gamer, he’s always playing with his little laptop. and then the whole thing where junpyo gave him a pizza stand :] adorable. now with susumu, the first thing that comes to mind when i think of him is his VOICE GOING THROUGH PUBERTY! gosh, his voice is constantly going through voice-cracking mode and it’s so annoying! do you guys know what i’m talking about???!?!?! lol. but i think the part where domyouji helped susumu get a girl was very cute and it was nice to see an actual teenage dilemma happen to susumu.

So after all’s said and done…

jandi's family wins!

jandi's family wins!

Jandi’s family wins. I think it’s because they just looked like a tight-knit family. In HYD at the TOJ, makino mentioned that “she loves her family no matter what” and so on, but i didn’t really see any evidence of that in HYD. They were all pretty distant from each other. Whereas in BBF, there was more interaction with jandi and the family, so i would believe that jandi loved her family and would put her life in suffering because she wanted them to be happy.

So that means the current standing in the HYD vs. BBF battle is 3 to 3. how convinient. hmm…what will the next one be? most likely i’ll be doing Domyouji’s mother vs. Jun pyo’s mother. or maybe i’ll start reviewing iconic scenes…hmm…the possibilities are endless! so just check back soon! As allllllwaaayyyys leave your comments and opinions! nothing makes me happier then to know what the readers are thinking. Thanks for reading and i hope to update veryyy soon!

peace, hydandbbfanalyst ❤

Advertisements

~ by jcstoy on August 6, 2009.

14 Responses to “HYD vs. BBF >>> Makino’s family vs. Jandi’s family”

  1. What a biasness ! Please can you tell me where are Jandi family at the end of the drama ? Jandi always shoot at her family like they are “spoiled fish”. Sorry but jandi all she think is Boys…She cries because of Boys, she sings “I only knows about boys and love” no wonder you hardly see her studies.
    When Makino punched Domyoji the first persons she though were her parents and How they struggled to educate her and feed her. When Domyoji mother came in Makino House to give her money, her mother defend her. She always worked hard (partime job, studying, overcome her friends’ tortures ect…) to help them. I mean how did you missed that ?

    • hey…”sorry”. Thanks for your opinions. I actually don’t try to show any biasness when i do these posts. If anything, i’d show a biass towards HYD for many reasons that mainly has to do with jun/mao chemistry. And i did watch the show and those parts you’re talking about and agree that makino did a great job trying to support her family and such, but i think that’s more of makino’s character, and i’ll talk about that when i review makino vs. jandi, but in this post, i’m just specifically reviewing the family members.
      Also, in BBF, Jandi’s mom also stands up to Junpyo’s mom and even goes to her house to beg for money which is love for her family. I mean, you can go to every post of mine where i said that BBF won and say i’m biassed, but i definitely don’t TRY to be biassed and everything i write, i try to back up with reasoning.
      But i will try to review (even) more carefully, thanks for commenting

    • i dont think this is biasness either becuase hydandbbfanalyst has a point. i think in bbf especially the part where jan di’s mom actually went to beg jun pyo’s mom that part wz really touching. yes makino’s mom did things too but i saw more of jandi’s mom. the drama went farther into her character then makino’s mom’s character. so i think hydandbbfanalyst is rite about bbf winning this one. 🙂

    • Hey you hypocrite. “sorry” but you are just as biased as the person who wrote this blog. When you do a versus, it’s basically YOURE opinion about the drama and in case your too dim to notice, your comment is biased torward YOUR views. Silly little child.
      good day to you.

  2. Oh ! Now you remember Makino worked a lot for her family. I am happy because it’s really unfair when you say that especially when you watched HYD and you saw Makino paticipated in TOJ because her family was in debt [In HYD at the TOJ, makino mentioned that “she loves her family no matter what” and so on, but i didn’t really see any evidence of that in HYD”].

    when you say “it’s more of Makino’s character”, you mean it’s normal if Makino (which is a character and not the actress) acts like that but in case of Jandi it’s not the case ? Isn’t Jandi supposed to be like Makino on this point ? Ok I will wait your next explaination on the characters.

    Plus through the elements you picked to support Jandi family (they are stick together, ect…) can you tell me where are Jandi family from the middle of the drama to the end ? Why, Jandi when she talks to her parents, she has to shoot as they are nothing ? Why in her thoughts all she can thinks is “boys” ? (frankly I had never seen her thinks about her parents what is not the case of Makino who wanted a better life for them [Indeed look at HYD epi 11 season 2]). Jandi mom went to beg JP’s one sorry but it’s out of character ! Makino parents (especially her mother) maybe somewhat greedy but they are not the kind who have no fighting spirit ! Makino’s mom will let nobody insults her daughter no matter the consequences ! And this is more touching and more encouraging ! And you can also understand Makino’s character. And please Susumu was much more developed than jandi brother and had a storyline too which was really useful for Makino and Domyji(and you can’t say the contrary even though you find Jandi brother more cute).
    Sorry but here Jandi’s family doesn’t deserve to win it’s so obvious (especially based on your arguments!)

  3. Oups sorry I did a mistake on this part “when you say “it’s more of Makino’s character”, you mean it’s normal if Makino (which is a character and not the actress) acts like that but in case of Jandi it’s not the case ? Isn’t Jandi supposed to be like Makino on this point ? Ok I will wait your next explaination on the characters.” I forgot to edit. I understand now.

    But I can’t complain on some others “BOF” wins. I do it only when your arguments are more clear and coherent with the results but not based on what you feel/or find more cute. Reade my posts and you will see all I say is taken from what you say.

  4. oh for the love of the lord, let’s argue about something a little more meangingful AND REAL then two dramas who’s basically, the whole point, was to tell the same story.
    lordy lordy good grief.

    wuv you little girl (:

  5. That’s weird nobody reply to my question. I repeat :
    “Plus through the elements you picked to support Jandi family (they are stick together, ect…) can you tell me where are Jandi family from the middle of the drama to the end ? Why, Jandi when she talks to her parents, she has to shoot as they are nothing ? Why in her thoughts all she can thinks is “boys” ?”

  6. I prefer Makino´s family over Jandí´s. I feel like they were most close and they care very much about Tsukushi. In the final movie it was very clear the parents chose her daughter´s happiness over all the money they could have if she married Tsukasa.

    I also missed Jandi´s family at the end of the drama.

  7. Hey guys..reality check..Jandi’s family is FICTION. While the lawyer in me loves a good debate- pls try to impart your points calmly. And so what if someone else has different opinions than you ..I enjoy reading her thoughts and would respect it as her thots. THanks

  8. i second this blog owner. i prefer jandi’s family.

  9. ummm okay here i dis agree…i think makino’s family is better than jan di’s family..i mean greediness is all over jandi’s mother’s face…i know its her character but compared to makino’s mother, jandi’s mother is greedier waaaaayyy greedier.. and i hate that..LOL! it’s like they don’t think about jan di..because they keep on doing and forcing jan di even though they know that jan di is already having a hard time. unlike jan di’s family you can feel the compassion and their love towards makino :)) especially if you watch the final and the season 2 of HYD 😀

  10. kang san :3

    i like the happy family 🙂 its really quite cute

  11. I know that this is pretty late, seeing as how the post was written in 2009, but anyway, I liked Makino’s Family better. It was because of her family that Tsukushi punched Tsukasa in the first place. Her family put a lot of work into her lunch box everyday and you could see how proud they were of her. Plus, I found their scenes hilarious! Also, Tsukushi’s mom stood up to Domyouji’s mom as well.

    Jandi’s family on the other hand, while cute, just didn’t really make as much of an impact on me. As others have mentioned, they were gone for about half of the drama. The acting wasn’t really good either. They overacted a lot and as a result, not a lot of real emotion was shown. Yes there were more mother/daughter scenes in BOF, however despite the amount, I didn’t feel the emotional connection. HYD, on the other, made use of the few scenes they had. ‘Quality not quantity’ comes to mind here.
    On a side note, Kang san’s laptop bugged me. I mean, they’re poor. How can they afford a laptop? And although Susumu was going through puberty, I really did like his portrayal of the little brother. Though kang san was cute.

    Either way, your opinion’s your opinion and I fully respect it. Just thought I’d give my side.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

 
%d bloggers like this: